Skip to main content

NYX Professional Colored Mascara vs Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner

Side-by-side comparison of NYX Professional Colored Mascara and Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner. Specs, pros, cons, and our recommendation.

What's the Difference?

The NYX Professional Colored Mascara and Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner are both eye products from NYX and Stila respectively. The NYX Professional Colored Mascara is the more budget-friendly option at $7-$12, making this a straightforward decision based on your priorities.

Where they differ: the NYX Professional Colored Mascara stands out for available in 8 vibrant shades including blue, purple, green, and burgundy, while the Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner excels at ultra-fine felt tip allows for precise lines from thin to thick. On the downside, the NYX Professional Colored Mascara's main concern is formula flakes and smudges after 4-6 hours of wear, and the Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner's is felt tip can dry out or fray with heavy use over time. Both are well-regarded with ratings of 4.2/5 and 4.3/5.

Choose the NYX Professional Colored Mascara if you prioritize available in 8 vibrant shades including blue, purple, green, and burgundy. Go with the Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner if ultra-fine felt tip allows for precise lines from thin to thick matters most.

NYX Professional Colored Mascara

NYX$7-$124.2/5

Budget-friendly colored mascara with decent pigment payoff, though formula tends to flake by midday.

Pros
  • Available in 8 vibrant shades including blue, purple, green, and burgundy
  • Buildable formula allows for subtle tint or bold color intensity
  • Curved brush separates lashes well without clumping
  • Affordable drugstore price point for experimenting with color
  • Removes easily with makeup remover or micellar water
Cons
  • Formula flakes and smudges after 4-6 hours of wear
  • Limited color payoff compared to higher-end colored mascaras
  • Can look patchy when layered over black mascara

Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner

Stila$22-$264.3/5

A precision felt-tip liquid liner with 16-hour wear that stays put through heat, humidity, and tears.

Pros
  • Ultra-fine felt tip allows for precise lines from thin to thick
  • Waterproof formula resists smudging, flaking, and fading for 16+ hours
  • Quick-dry formula sets in seconds without tugging on delicate eye skin
  • Intense black pigmentation requires only one coat for full opacity
  • Easy removal with oil-based makeup remover despite long wear
Cons
  • Felt tip can dry out or fray with heavy use over time
  • Difficult to remove completely without proper oil-based remover
  • Limited to one shade (intense black) in most retailers

Our Pick: Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner

With a 4.3/5 rating, the Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner edges ahead. A precision felt-tip liquid liner with 16-hour wear that stays put through heat, humidity, and tears.

This article may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

More from our network